20 Oct 2017

Nicola Sturgeon has once again stated that she will push ahead with trials of a citizen’s income, despite having been told that the plan is unfeasible.

Speaking in Glasgow today Sturgeon said, “We are also going to work with interested local authorities to fund research into the feasibility of a citizen’s basic income scheme.”

While she admitted that “it might turn out not to be feasible”, a civil service briefing handed to her in March already stated that the policy was a non-starter, and would cost taxpayers £12.3 billion a year.

The Scottish Conservatives have said that it shows just how far the First Minister is willing to go in order to keep the left flank of the independence movement on side.

Scottish Conservative shadow social security secretary Adam Tomkins MSP said:

“Nicola Sturgeon has already been told unequivocally that the idea of a citizen’s income is a non-starter.

“Her civil servants stated to her that the idea it is totally unaffordable and unsustainable, yet she is continuing to press ahead with this trial despite knowing better.

“It simply shows the lengths that this First Minister will go to appease the extreme left of the pro-independence movement.

“Rather than pursue futile projects such as this she should be using government resources on schemes that actually stand a chance of improving the lives of Scots.”

19 Oct 2017

Around one in eight out of hours shifts in GP surgeries are left unfilled, a study has suggested.

Analysis of shifts in doctor surgeries at nights and weekends showed 12.8 per cent were vacant across the country.

In some health boards, more than a quarter of shifts went unfilled.

The statistics were obtained by the Scottish Conservatives, who asked for a snapshot of GP out of hours staff cover during a week in May in a bid to uncover the extent of the problem.

The responses indicate widespread staffing difficulties in GP surgeries north of the border.

Already this year it’s been reported that a quarter of trainee posts in local practices are empty, while experts have warned there will be a shortfall of more than 800 doctors within a few years.

The SNP’s disastrous workforce planning over recent years – despite being repeatedly warned about the challenges brought by an ageing population – has been blamed for the crisis.

The Scottish Conservatives have called for a larger proportion of the health budget to be invested in primary care in an attempt to improve service, take the strain off GPs, and make things easier for other parts of the NHS further down the line.

Shadow health secretary Miles Briggs warned that rate of unfilled shifts would be even more problematic as the winter months approach.

Scottish Conservative shadow health secretary Miles Briggs said:

“This is yet another indication of the GP crisis which is gripping Scotland.

“It’s incredible to think around one in eight GP out of hours shifts can’t be filled purely because the SNP hasn’t bothered to plan for the future properly.

“The NHS is on its knees in a number of areas, but that is particularly apparent in local GP practices.

“It means patients can’t get the help they need, and the hardworking doctors left behind are becoming increasingly over-stretched.

“And with the winter months well on their way, this crisis could have even more severe consequences.

“The SNP government has let it get to this stage, and now has to explain to patients north of the border what it is going to do to address it.”

The Scottish Conservatives asked all health boards for the percentage of unfilled out of hours shifts in GP practices for the week commencing May 22, 2017. The responses can be accessed here:
http://www.scottishconservatives.com/wordpress/wp-content/uploads/2017/10/OOHResponses.zip

Below is the proportion of unfilled out of hours GP shifts by health board for that week:

NHS Ayrshire and Arran – 16.4 per cent
NHS Borders – 4.5 per cent
NHS Dumfries and Galloway – 5.5 per cent
NHS Fife – n/a
NHS Forth Valley – 26 per cent
NHS Greater Glasgow and Clyde – 4 per cent
NHS Grampian – 7 per cent
NHS Highland – n/a
NHS Lanarkshire – 11.6 per cent
NHS Lothian – 7 per cent
NHS Orkney – 0
NHS Shetland – 0
NHS Tayside – 4.8 per cent
NHS Western Isles – 0

Scotland – 12.8 per cent

18 Oct 2017

Nicola Sturgeon pressed ahead with plans to trial a basic income for everyone – despite civil servant briefings showing her it would cost taxpayers £12.3 billion a year.

Documents obtained by the Scottish Conservatives through Freedom of Information have revealed the briefing on Citizen’s Basic Income (CBI) handed to the First Minister in March.

It warned the plans would cost billions extra every year, and lead to every income tax payer in the country having to cough up a rate of 50 per cent.

The briefing stated: “It is a very costly policy that is unlikely to gain public acceptability and ultimately may not have the desired transformative effect.”

The document was given to Nicola Sturgeon, finance secretary Derek Mackay, social security secretary Angela Constance and minister Jeane Freeman on March 2 by Liz Hawkins, the Scottish Government’s housing and social justice director.

It warned CBI would “have little incentivising impact” and that “most governments will not be able to afford both CBI and a generous welfare state”.

Experts also said it was “more likely to further entrench gender stereotyping”.

Despite this, last month Nicola Sturgeon spoke of her fondness for the approach while unveiling her Programme for Government.

She told MSPs: “It is an idea that merits deeper consideration. I can therefore confirm that the Scottish Government will work with interested local authorities to fund research into the concept and feasibility of a citizen’s basic income.”

This was reinforced as part of her keynote SNP conference speech earlier this month, where she said: “Last year, this conference asked us to investigate the feasibility of a citizen’s basic income. So we’ve announced the funding to do just that.”

Scottish Conservative shadow social security secretary Adam Tomkins said:

“Nicola Sturgeon and her finance team were told in no uncertain terms that a scheme for citizen’s basic income would be utterly unaffordable and not remotely sustainable.

“Despite these stark warnings, she continued to create an impression that she was going to introduce it.

“This suggests she is pandering to the extreme left of the Yes movement in the hope they won’t turn on her over poor polling and the fact separation is dead in the water.

“But this briefing makes plain just how unworkable the CBI approach would be.

“Instead of playing to the gallery, the First Minister should explain exactly where she’s going to find the extra £12.3 billion that would be required each year to fund it.

“Or perhaps she’d like to tell taxpayers, including those on low incomes, that they’ll have to give back half their pay packet to bankroll this vanity project.

“At the start of the year I was able to look into the feasibility of CBI and quickly conclude it would be damaging and impossible.

“It shouldn’t be beyond the wit of the SNP government to do the same.”

17 Oct 2017

Justice secretary Michael Matheson has been criticised for shirking responsibility for Police Scotland – after dodging a series of questions on the single force.

The Scottish Conservatives have highlighted six recent parliamentary questions when he was asked specifically about the country’s police service.

But instead of providing the information, he instead used a “copy and paste approach” to claim only Police Scotland itself could explain such matters.

Last week, when asked how many chief inspector posts were unfilled, Mr Matheson said it was “a matter for the chief constable”.

A month earlier, he used an identical excuse when challenged on the performance of control rooms.

In August, shadow justice secretary Liam Kerr sought information on overtime costs at the troubled Police Scotland control centre in Dundee, and how many staff were employed there.

Days earlier he asked about a recent IT failing there which led to reports of police officers being unable to call on back-up.

On both occasions, Mr Matheson refused to answer, again saying it was the chief constable’s responsibility.

And as far back as February this year, he described as a “matter for the chief constable” the issue of a database for vulnerable persons.

Scottish Conservative shadow justice secretary Liam Kerr said:

“This is the behaviour of a justice secretary who doesn’t want to take responsibility for his brief.

“If Michael Matheson doesn’t think policing matters are for him to get involved in, what exactly does he do with his day?

“It’s not good enough for him to constantly issue a copy and paste response to important matters like the safety of officers, policing numbers and the wellbeing of vulnerable people.

“The fact there isn’t even a working chief constable to refer these matters to at the moment makes this scenario all the more ridiculous.

“It’s time Mr Matheson stepped up and took some responsibility for policing in Scotland.

“The SNP government created Police Scotland – it can’t now simply retreat and pretend it has nothing to do with it now.”

13 Oct 2017

Nicola Sturgeon and eight of her top team have been accused of using ministerial cars to travel from party political events.

It was reported today that eight cabinet ministers used taxpayer-funded vehicles to leave the SNP General Election manifesto launch in Perth in May.

Now it has been revealed that the First Minister travelled in an official vehicle to and from a campaign event in Stirling on April 26, where she was famously photographed posing on an independence-branded motorbike.

Both incidents appear to be in breach of the Ministerial Code, which states: “Ministers must not use public resources for party political purposes.”

Information published this week showed John Swinney, Derek Mackay, Shona Robison, Fiona Hyslop, Alasdair Allan, Maureen Watt, Paul Wheelhouse and Fergus Ewing all clambered into ministerial cars following the launch on May 30.

None of them listed a ministerial engagement on that day.

This followed the example of Ms Sturgeon a few days earlier, who even the SNP campaign diary admits “was in Stirling today to meet voters and visit local businesses”.

Scottish Conservative MSP Miles Briggs said:

“The public will be deeply uncomfortable at the idea of eight ministers swanning out of such a party political event and straight into a taxpayer-funded car.

“And they obviously took their lead from Nicola Sturgeon a few days earlier, who may have enjoyed posing on a Yes-themed motorbike for a publicity stunt.

“But what the cameras didn’t pick up was the taxpayer-funded fancy car waiting round the corner.

“It’s the kind of hypocrisy and abuse the SNP is becoming renowned for.

“Anyone can see just how political events like a manifesto launch or photocall are, and the ministerial code clearly states this kind of thing would be a breach.

“If it was one minister, attending one government event, you could probably forgive this as an oversight.

“But for half the cabinet and the First Minister to be involved reeks of privileged complacency.

“SNP ministers seem to have forgotten that these cars are paid for by the public, and they risk not being taken seriously when they complain about limited resources available.”

Notes to editors:

For more on the story featuring eight ministers getting official cars from the SNP manifesto launch, visit:

http://www.heraldscotland.com/news/15594255.SNP_leadership_accused_of__abuse__of_public_funds_over_manifesto_launch/

The full data publications are available on the Scottish Government website (Ministerial engagements, travel and gifts, 11 October 2017, link, link, link)

• Sturgeon and eight SNP ministers appear breached the code of conduct. Section 1.2.(i) of the Ministerial Code of Conduct states: ‘Ministers must not use public resources for party political purposes’ (Scottish Ministerial Code, August 2016 p2, link).

• Sturgeon’s visit to Stirling was clearly a campaign event. She was photographed on an independence-branded motorbike and the SNP website lists Sturgeon on the campaign trail (SNP website, 26 April 2017, link; Scottish Sun, 26 April 2017, link).

• Eight ministers used a ministerial car to travel from Perth Concert Hall to various locations on 30 May 2017. The SNP launched their General Election Manifesto 2017 at Perth Concert Hall on 30 May. None of these eight ministers have listed an engagement in Perth on 30 May (Scottish Government, Ministerial engagements, travel and gifts: May 2017, 11 October 2017, link).